Hip and groin pain in a young, active patient is often associated with femoroacetabular impingement syndrome (FAIS), particularly cam or pincer morphology. However, not every patient presenting with impingement-type symptoms has a stiff or structurally restricted hip.
Some patients present with almost the opposite picture: a highly mobile hip, pain towards the end of range and difficulty controlling the femoral head and pelvis during activity. This presentation is increasingly described as hypermobile hip impingement, hip microinstability or dynamic hip instability.
The terminology continues to evolve and does not represent one universally accepted diagnosis. However, recognising this clinical pattern is important because the management can be very different.
Rather than trying to increase hip mobility, treatment often needs to focus on improving muscular control, strength and load tolerance while reducing repeated provocative end-range loading.
Case presentation
A 26-year-old female recreational runner presented with persistent anterior and central groin pain.
Her symptoms had initially been intermittent, particularly after prolonged sitting and first thing in the morning. She described the hip as feeling stiff and frequently felt the need to stand, move or stretch it.
Over time, her symptoms became more persistent. Sitting for more than approximately an hour became uncomfortable, and she started using a standing desk. Running remained possible initially, but pain developed after several kilometres and increased as her training volume or intensity increased.
Other aggravating activities included:
- deep squats and lunges
- exercises involving deep hip flexion
- prolonged sitting
- yoga positions involving deep flexion, abduction and external rotation, particularly pigeon pose
- higher-volume or more intense running.
She had previously been advised to stretch her hip flexors. However, this did not reliably improve her symptoms and sometimes aggravated her groin pain.
Her history also included medial tibial stress syndrome and previous stress-related lower-limb problems. This was clinically important: in a runner presenting with progressive groin pain, femoral-neck or pelvic bone stress injury needs to be considered rather than assuming symptoms are solely related to the hip joint or surrounding soft tissues.
A mobile hip – but is it a controlled hip?
On examination of the hip, the patient was notably flexible, with a large range of hip movement, including substantial flexion and rotation. This was not the typical presentation of a hip that appeared mechanically blocked or restricted.
Importantly, a large range of movement is not in itself pathological.
Many highly flexible people are completely asymptomatic.
For the clinician, more useful questions include:
- Is the end of range painful?
- Does movement produce apprehension or a feeling of slipping or giving way?
- Can the patient control the pelvis and femur throughout the movement?
- Is the range actively controlled or predominantly passive?
- Do symptoms develop following repeated end-range loading?
Assessment should therefore extend beyond simply measuring range of movement.
Clinical examination may include FADIR and FABER testing, log-roll testing, resisted hip flexion and straight-leg raise, iliopsoas and adductor provocation, lumbar and sacroiliac screening and assessment of single-leg control. Generalised joint hypermobility can also be assessed, including with a Beighton score where appropriate.
A high Beighton score may support the presence of generalised hypermobility, but it does not establish hip instability. Conversely, a patient can have symptomatic local hip hypermobility without being generally hypermobile.
Hypermobile hip impingement versus classical FAIS

The traditional FAI presentation is usually associated with cam morphology, pincer morphology or a combination of the two. Clinically, the patient may demonstrate reduced hip flexion and internal rotation, a relatively firm or painful end-feel and pain with flexion, adduction and internal rotation.
The underlying mechanical problem is often premature contact between the femoral head-neck junction and the acetabular rim.
The hypermobile presentation can look very different.
These patients may have:
- large hip flexion and rotational ranges
- pain towards the end of range
- symptoms during combined flexion and rotation
- apprehension with certain movements
- a sensation of the hip moving or slipping
- pain following repeated activity
- evidence of labral or capsular overload.
In these patients, the hip may not be painful because it cannot move far enough, but because it moves too far or repeatedly reaches end range without sufficient dynamic control.
A positive FADIR test can still occur, but this finding alone cannot determine whether symptoms are primarily related to cam morphology, labral pathology, dysplasia, instability or soft-tissue overload.
What else needs to be considered?
Bone stress injury
Femoral-neck or pelvic bone stress injury is an important differential diagnosis, particularly in runners and athletes with previous bone stress problems.
Progressively declining running tolerance, pain during walking, rest or night pain, limping and pain with hopping or axial loading should increase clinical suspicion.
Where femoral-neck stress injury is suspected, running should be stopped while appropriate imaging is arranged. Early plain radiographs may be normal, and MRI may therefore be required where clinical suspicion remains high.
Listen to this podcast episode on a patient’s journey following hip stress fracture.
Acetabular dysplasia
Acetabular dysplasia or borderline acetabular coverage can reduce the bony containment of the femoral head, increasing load through the labrum and capsule and potentially contributing to instability.
The lateral centre-edge angle is commonly used when assessing acetabular coverage, although it should not be interpreted in isolation. Pelvic position, acetabular version and radiographic technique can all affect the measurement.
Crucially, a normal lateral centre-edge angle does not exclude dynamic instability. Capsular laxity, excessive translation, anterior undercoverage and poor muscular control can still be present.
Labral pathology
Labral abnormalities may occur alongside dysplasia, repeated instability, pivoting or traumatic injury.
However, identifying a labral tear does not necessarily mean it is the primary cause of symptoms. In some patients it may be a consequence of excessive movement or insufficient acetabular coverage.
This distinction is important when considering treatment: addressing the labrum alone may not solve the problem if underlying instability remains.
Iliopsoas and rectus femoris
Iliopsoas-related pain can also present as anterior groin pain, particularly with resisted hip flexion, running and repeated hip-flexor loading.
In a hypermobile hip, the iliopsoas may potentially become overloaded as it contributes to anterior hip stability. This provides another reason why repeatedly stretching the hip flexors may be unhelpful in selected patients.
Proximal rectus femoris pathology and adductor-related groin pain should also be considered as part of the differential diagnosis.
The role of musculoskeletal ultrasound
Bedside musculoskeletal ultrasound can be a useful adjunct when assessing anterior hip and groin pain, providing dynamic, real-time assessment of accessible structures.
It can be particularly helpful when assessing:
- the rectus femoris and its AIIS insertion
- the iliopsoas tendon and bursa
- the anterior hip joint recess and joint effusion
- accessible anterior joint and labral structures
- paralabral cysts
- dynamic tendon movement.
Dynamic scanning can be especially useful where snapping or abnormal tendon movement is suspected.
However, ultrasound findings must always be interpreted alongside the clinical presentation. Minor tendon and labral changes can be present in asymptomatic people.
It is equally important to recognise the limitations of ultrasound. A reassuring ultrasound examination does not exclude a labral tear, early cartilage injury, bone stress injury, dysplasia or dynamic instability.
Radiographs and MRI therefore remain important where significant intra-articular or bony pathology is suspected.
Management – control rather than more mobility

The initial aim is to reduce irritation while maintaining appropriate activity and avoiding unnecessary fear of movement.
Activities repeatedly provoking end-range symptoms may need to be temporarily modified. These can include deep squatting and lunging, extreme hip rotation, aggressive hip-flexor stretching, high-volume running, sprinting and exercises that reproduce sharp groin pain or apprehension.
The emphasis of rehabilitation should then be on active stability rather than increasing passive range.
Progressive rehabilitation may target the gluteal muscles, deep hip rotators, adductors, hip flexors and trunk musculature alongside single-leg and running-specific control.
The principal goals are to improve:
- pelvic and femoral control
- single-leg stability
- strength throughout a controlled range
- tolerance to progressive loading
- confidence with movement
- eventual running and sporting capacity.
One particularly useful clinical message is that a patient’s description of “stiffness” does not necessarily mean they require more stretching.
The sensation can result from pain, protective muscle activity, fatigue, iliopsoas overactivity or poor movement control. If stretching reproduces groin pain or causes a subsequent increase in symptoms, it should be modified or stopped.
For a genuinely hypermobile hip, the objective is not to create additional range. It is to develop sufficient strength and control to use the available range effectively.
When should specialist assessment be considered?
Persistent symptoms, suspected dysplasia, significant labral pathology, recurrent instability, possible bone stress injury or failure to progress with appropriate rehabilitation should prompt further investigation or specialist hip assessment.
Surgical decision-making also requires particular care in this population.
Hip arthroscopy may have a role in selected patients with significant labral pathology, persistent mechanical symptoms or another clearly treatable structural lesion. However, where instability or inadequate acetabular coverage is the primary problem, treating the labrum alone may not address the underlying cause.
Capsular integrity, acetabular coverage, femoral and acetabular morphology and cartilage status therefore need to be considered as part of the wider clinical picture.
Key points for referrers
When assessing a young or athletic patient with persistent hip or groin pain:
- Do not assume that groin pain and a positive FADIR test automatically indicate classical FAI.
- A highly mobile hip can still produce impingement-type symptoms.
- Pain at end range is different from restriction of range.
- Ask about apprehension, slipping, giving way and symptoms following repeated activity.
- Be cautious about repeatedly prescribing hip-flexor stretching to a highly mobile patient.
- Consider femoral-neck or pelvic bone stress injury in runners with progressive groin pain.
- Consider acetabular coverage, labral pathology and capsular laxity when instability is suspected.
- Use ultrasound as part of the clinical picture rather than as a means of excluding all intra-articular pathology.
- Rehabilitation should prioritise strength, active control and graded loading rather than automatically trying to increase mobility.
The take-home message
Hip impingement is not always a problem of a hip that is too stiff.
In patients with substantial hip mobility, symptoms may instead be associated with excessive movement, insufficient dynamic control, capsular laxity, acetabular dysplasia or borderline coverage, and secondary overload of structures such as the labrum and iliopsoas.
Recognising this pattern matters. Advising an already highly mobile patient to repeatedly stretch into provocative positions may aggravate symptoms, while a rehabilitation programme focused on strength, pelvic control and graded loading can address the factors contributing to dynamic stability.
For referrers, considering how well the patient controls their available range – rather than simply how much range they have – can be an important part of understanding persistent hip and groin pain.
References
- Griffin DR, Dickenson EJ, O’Donnell J, et al. The Warwick Agreement on femoroacetabular impingement syndrome: an international consensus statement. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2016;50(19):1169–1176.
- Ganz R, Parvizi J, Beck M, et al. Femoroacetabular impingement: a cause for osteoarthritis of the hip. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. 2003;417:112–120.
- Shu B, Safran MR. Hip instability: anatomic and clinical considerations of traumatic and atraumatic instability. Clinics in Sports Medicine. 2011;30(2):349–367.
- Kalisvaart MM, Safran MR. Microinstability of the hip—it does exist: etiology, diagnosis and treatment. Journal of Hip Preservation Surgery. 2015;2(2):123–135.
- Wylie JD, Beckmann JT, Maak TG. Arthroscopic capsular repair and plication for hip instability. Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. 2019;27(10)–e477.
- Lund B. Hip arthroscopy in the setting of hip dysplasia. Journal of Hip Preservation Surgery. 2018;5(3):256–265.
- Reiman MP, Goode AP, Cook CE, et al. Diagnostic accuracy of clinical tests for femoroacetabular impingement and labral pathology: a systematic review. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2015;49(12):811.
- Weber AE, Khan M, Zbeda RM, et al. Current concepts in the management of the painful borderline dysplastic hip. Journal of Hip Preservation Surgery. 2019;6(1):1–13.
- Domb BG, Chaharbakhshi EO, Perets I, et al. Physical examination of the hip in the athlete: a systematic approach to diagnosis. Journal of Hip Preservation Surgery. 2017;4(4):331–342.


